Closed Thanksgiving Day, Nov 26 · Feasts to go, preorder by Nov 20

Waterloo, New York

Come as you are.
Stay awhile.

Seasonal, chef-driven, farm-to-table dining in Waterloo, in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Chef-owned, with local wine, craft cocktails, and ingredients sourced with intention.

Reserve a table
The bar at Starr’s Restaurant in Waterloo, NY, with wooden stools and a flower garland

No pretense, just care in every detail. A three-course dinner here unfolds over an hour to an hour and a half, made to order and meant to be savored, not rushed.


How to Starr’s

Tonight

Walk in, or reserve on OpenTable. Wednesday is Pasta Night and Thursday brings oysters and bubbly. Whatever the night, the kitchen cooks to order.

See the menu

Date night

Begin with a drink and something to share, settle into a steak or the catch of the week, and take your time. Dinner runs an hour to an hour and a half.

Reserve a table

Milestones

Rehearsal dinners, birthdays, retirements. The Loft seats 46 with room for 70 more standing, and there is no room fee.

Plan your celebration
Glazed salmon over greens and grains, a current dinner at Starr’s A crisp, tall plated starter on a blue stoneware bowl An apple martini on the bar, surrounded by small autumn pumpkins

The room

A hand-painted heron among lotus flowers on the wall of the dining room at Starr’s A jar of pink tulips and a lit candle on a table against the exposed brick wall at Starr’s

We’ll let them tell it

“Best steak ever had. My wife had a New York strip, I had the ribeye. Absolutely delicious, as was rest of meal. Turned out to be most expensive meal we ever ate, cause now we have to drive 8hrs to New York every time we want steak. But worth it.”
Sherry Chamberlin
“Definitely a hidden gem! My steak was perfect, the portions are fantastic, friendly service and atmosphere, and the food is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! I don’t typically give 5 star ratings, but this place definitely earns it!!!! I can’t wait to try the Duck breast!!!”
Nichelle Edgar
“May have not discovered Starr’s Restaurant if not for an invite from friends. Gorgeous place. Food was top notch. Menu pushed me slightly out of my comfort zone and it was completely worth it. Sampled other dishes at the table as well. Everything was great.”
Denver Miller
“Starr’s was hands down the BEST food i have ever had in my entire life. In all 37 years nothing was as good as this. The duck frite was a new experience and we loved it. The steaks were top of the top quality and cooked to beyond perfection. Truthfully i am at a loss for words on how to describe the taste of everything. The waitress was extremely nice and helpful and knowledgeable about everything, drinks included. She even made me an item that wasn’t on the menu and then a drink that she herself created on the spot. Heavenly. This place is a 5 star restaurant that has proudly earned those stars. This is an absolute MUST for everyone.”
Majin

Make a reservation


Visit

7 E. Main Street
Waterloo, NY 13165
(315) 759-7133 (call or text)
info@starrsrestaurant.com

Hours of operation
Monday & TuesdayClosedOpen Monday, Nov 30, 5 to 10 pm for the Uncrustable Soiree.
WednesdayPasta Night & Girls Night Cocktails. No regular menu.4:30 to 9
ThursdayOyster & Bubbly specials4:30 to 9Closed Thursday, Nov 26 for Thanksgiving. Back open Friday.
Friday & Saturday4:30 to 10
SundayClosed